Harvard ILJ Harvard ILJ Harvard International Law Journal
  • Subscribe to RSS
  • About
    • Masthead
    • Board of Advisors
    • Information For 1Ls
    • Contact
  • Print Edition
    • Print Archives
  • Features & Commentary
    • Op-Ed
    • Live Blog
    • Past Liveblogs
      • 2012 ILJ Symposium
    • Article Series
    • Print Responses
    • Profiles
    • Student Commentaries
    • Symposium Forum
    • Online Archives
  • Symposium
    • Symposium Archives
  • Submissions
    • Print Submissions
    • Online Submissions
    • Student Submissions
  • Subscriptions
    • Print Edition
    • Newsletter
    • RSS Feeds
Posted on 12:32 pm | Posted in Features & Commentary, Symposium, Symposium Forum

Targeted Killing, Human Rights and Ungoverned Spaces:

Considering Territorial State Human Rights Obligations
By John C. Dehn
Suggested Bluebook citation: John C. Dehn, Targeted Killing, Human Rights and Ungoverned Spaces: Considering Territorial State Human Rights Obligations, 54 Harv. Int'l L.J. Online 84 (2013), http://www.harvardilj.org/2013/01/online_54_deh/.
John C. Dehn is a senior fellow at the West Point Center for the Rule of Law and a judge advocate, U.S. Army.
Download Article
Share Article:
Share 'Targeted Killing, Human Rights and Ungoverned Spaces' on Delicious Share 'Targeted Killing, Human Rights and Ungoverned Spaces' on Digg Share 'Targeted Killing, Human Rights and Ungoverned Spaces' on Facebook Share 'Targeted Killing, Human Rights and Ungoverned Spaces' on Google Buzz Share 'Targeted Killing, Human Rights and Ungoverned Spaces' on MySpace Share 'Targeted Killing, Human Rights and Ungoverned Spaces' on reddit Share 'Targeted Killing, Human Rights and Ungoverned Spaces' on StumbleUpon Share 'Targeted Killing, Human Rights and Ungoverned Spaces' on Technorati Share 'Targeted Killing, Human Rights and Ungoverned Spaces' on Tumblr Share 'Targeted Killing, Human Rights and Ungoverned Spaces' on Twitter Share 'Targeted Killing, Human Rights and Ungoverned Spaces' on Yahoo! Buzz Share 'Targeted Killing, Human Rights and Ungoverned Spaces' on Email

An Article in the Series: State Ethics: Controlling the Behavior of Governments and their Partners

This brief commentary considers the potential effect of a territorial state’s international human rights obligations on the law governing targeted killings. It posits that these obligations should limit permissible attacks by an attacking state when the territorial state is not party to an armed conflict with the relevant non-state actor, particularly when a territorial state consents to the attacking state’s actions. It also argues that a territorial state’s extraterritorial human rights obligations provides support for an attacking state’s right to resort to force in the territorial state when it fails to suppress a resident threat. It concludes by briefly suggesting that recognizing the necessity of effective governance to the preservation of human rights could prompt the development of an international law of ungoverned spaces, perhaps best thought of as “international martial law.”

Read Article (PDF Format) --- [Get Adobe Reader]

Tags: featured, Human Rights, Laws of War and Humanitarian Law

Other articles in the Series "State Ethics: Controlling the Behavior of Governments and their Partners":
  • Christof Heyns & Sarah Knuckey: The Long-Term International Law Implications of Targeted Killing Practices
  • Susan Brenner: Offensive Economic Espionage?

John C. Dehn, Targeted Killing, Human Rights and Ungoverned Spaces: Considering Territorial State Human Rights Obligations, 54 Harv. Int'l L.J. Online 84 (2013), http://www.harvardilj.org/2013/01/online_54_deh/.

The Journal:

The Harvard International Law Journal is the oldest and most-cited student-edited journal of international and comparative law.
 
DOWN
  • Latest in Print
  • Latest Online
  • The Failed Promise of Language Rights: A Critique of the International Language Rights Regime The Failed Promise of Language Rights: A Critique of the International Language Rights Regime Moria Paz, Volume 54(1)
  • Consent to the Use of Force and International Law Supremacy Consent to the Use of Force and International Law Supremacy Ashley S. Deeks, Volume 54(1)
  • Getting to Rights: Treaty Ratification, Constitutional Convergence, and Human Rights Practice Getting to Rights: Treaty Ratification, Constitutional Convergence, and Human Rights Practice Zachary Elkins, Tom Ginsburg and Beth Simmons, Volume 54(1)
  • International Vote Buying International Vote Buying Natalie J. Lockwood, Volume 54(1)
  • Conceptualizing China Within the Kantian Peace Conceptualizing China Within the Kantian Peace Manik V. Suri, Volume 54(2)
  • The Enforcement of Foreign Copyright Judgments in U.S. Courts and the First Amendment Commentary ~ The Enforcement of Foreign Copyright Judgments in U.S. Courts and the First Amendment Claire Guehenno
  • International Law as American History Commentary ~ International Law as American History Marco Basile
  • Reciprocity and the Regulatory Function of International Investment Law Response ~ Reciprocity and the Regulatory Function of International Investment Law Julian Davis Mortenson
  • Forum ~ HILJ Symposium Cecilia Vogel
  • Forum ~ HILJ Symposium Ankita Ritwik

Newsletter

Sign up for the Harvard ILJ Newsletter and never miss an article!

 
DOWN
  • Home
  • Contact
  • Archive
  • RSS Feeds
  • Members

A Student-Run Publication At Harvard Law School - The Harvard Law School’s name and/or shield are trademarks of the President and Fellows of Harvard College and are used by permission of Harvard University