Harvard ILJ Harvard ILJ Harvard International Law Journal
  • Subscribe to RSS
  • About
    • Masthead
    • Board of Advisors
    • Information For 1Ls
    • Contact
  • Print Edition
    • Print Archives
  • Features & Commentary
    • Op-Ed
    • Live Blog
    • Past Liveblogs
      • 2012 ILJ Symposium
    • Article Series
    • Print Responses
    • Profiles
    • Student Commentaries
    • Symposium Forum
    • Online Archives
  • Symposium
    • Symposium Archives
  • Submissions
    • Print Submissions
    • Online Submissions
    • Student Submissions
  • Subscriptions
    • Print Edition
    • Newsletter
    • RSS Feeds
Posted on 9:00 am | Posted in Article Series

Between Religious Freedom and Equality:

Complexity and Context
By Carolyn Evans and Beth Gaze
Suggested Bluebook citation: Carolyn Evans and Beth Gaze, Between Religious Freedom and Equality: Complexity and Context, 49 Harv. Int'l L.J. Online 40 (2008), http://www.harvardilj.org/2008/04/online_49_evans_gaze/.
The authors are scholars at the Centre for Comparative Constitutional Studies, Melbourne Law School, Australia. This article forms part of a broader project on the relationship between religious freedom and non-discrimination funded by an Australian Research Council Discovery Grant.
Download Article
Share Article:
Share 'Between Religious Freedom and Equality' on Delicious Share 'Between Religious Freedom and Equality' on Digg Share 'Between Religious Freedom and Equality' on Facebook Share 'Between Religious Freedom and Equality' on Google Buzz Share 'Between Religious Freedom and Equality' on MySpace Share 'Between Religious Freedom and Equality' on reddit Share 'Between Religious Freedom and Equality' on StumbleUpon Share 'Between Religious Freedom and Equality' on Technorati Share 'Between Religious Freedom and Equality' on Tumblr Share 'Between Religious Freedom and Equality' on Twitter Share 'Between Religious Freedom and Equality' on Yahoo! Buzz Share 'Between Religious Freedom and Equality' on Email

An Article in the Series: Faith in the Courts: Global Perspectives on Law and Religion

As one of its goals, the Harvard ILJ strives to publish timely and relevant scholarship that addresses current developments and issues in international, comparative, and foreign law. In that spirit, the ILJ is proud to publish this article series "Faith in the Courts: Global Perspectives on Law and Religion." Through contributions from academics, judges, practitioners, and other scholars, the articles in this series will explore questions related to religious freedom and accommodation between religion and state in a variety of international and comparative law contexts.

Introduction*

The tension between religious freedom and non-discrimination principles is becoming increasingly acute. International human rights treaties usually affirm the importance of both equality and of religious freedom, often with little guidance as to how the two are to be reconciled in the many contexts in which they come into conflict. Questions about the appropriate way to balance the two rights arise with particular regularity around discrimination on the basis of sex, sexuality and religious discrimination. Should patriarchal religions be forced to admit women clergy – or at

least lose their tax exemptions if they do not? Should religious employers be able to give preference to co-religionists or to dismiss those who do not uphold the teachings of the employer religion? Should religious schools that receive state funding be required to admit all students regardless of their religion, sex or sexual orientation? These questions have become more urgent with the increasing reliance on religious groups to provide services such as education, health, assistance with employment, welfare, adoption and a myriad of other schemes, often as part of government policies that rely on private provision of government services.

…

* This excerpt does not include citations. To read the entire article, including supporting notes, please download the PDF.

Read Article (PDF Format) --- [Get Adobe Reader]
Other articles in the Series "Faith in the Courts: Global Perspectives on Law and Religion":
  • Ayelet Shachar: Entangled: State, Religion, and the Family
  • Nicholas Hatzis: Neutrality, Proselytism, and Religious Minorities at the European Court of Human Rights and the U.S. Supreme Court
  • Ran Hirschl: The Rise of Constitutional Theocracy
  • Samantha Knights: Sacred Space and the City: Religious Buildings and Noise Pollution
  • Robin Hopkins and Can V. Yeginsu: Religious Liberty in British Courts: A Critique and Some Guidance

Carolyn Evans and Beth Gaze, Between Religious Freedom and Equality: Complexity and Context, 49 Harv. Int'l L.J. Online 40 (2008), http://www.harvardilj.org/2008/04/online_49_evans_gaze/.

The Journal:

The Harvard International Law Journal is the oldest and most-cited student-edited journal of international and comparative law.
 
DOWN
  • Latest in Print
  • Latest Online
  • The Failed Promise of Language Rights: A Critique of the International Language Rights Regime The Failed Promise of Language Rights: A Critique of the International Language Rights Regime Moria Paz, Volume 54(1)
  • Consent to the Use of Force and International Law Supremacy Consent to the Use of Force and International Law Supremacy Ashley S. Deeks, Volume 54(1)
  • Getting to Rights: Treaty Ratification, Constitutional Convergence, and Human Rights Practice Getting to Rights: Treaty Ratification, Constitutional Convergence, and Human Rights Practice Zachary Elkins, Tom Ginsburg and Beth Simmons, Volume 54(1)
  • International Vote Buying International Vote Buying Natalie J. Lockwood, Volume 54(1)
  • Conceptualizing China Within the Kantian Peace Conceptualizing China Within the Kantian Peace Manik V. Suri, Volume 54(2)
  • The Enforcement of Foreign Copyright Judgments in U.S. Courts and the First Amendment Commentary ~ The Enforcement of Foreign Copyright Judgments in U.S. Courts and the First Amendment Claire Guehenno
  • International Law as American History Commentary ~ International Law as American History Marco Basile
  • Reciprocity and the Regulatory Function of International Investment Law Response ~ Reciprocity and the Regulatory Function of International Investment Law Julian Davis Mortenson
  • Forum ~ HILJ Symposium Cecilia Vogel
  • Forum ~ HILJ Symposium Ankita Ritwik

Newsletter

Sign up for the Harvard ILJ Newsletter and never miss an article!

 
DOWN
  • Home
  • Contact
  • Archive
  • RSS Feeds
  • Members

A Student-Run Publication At Harvard Law School - The Harvard Law School’s name and/or shield are trademarks of the President and Fellows of Harvard College and are used by permission of Harvard University